你的大学教学质量硬不硬，相信许多在念大学和即将念大学的小伙伴都很关心。但是，从哪里可以知道大学的教学质量呢？

2017年6月22日，根据《泰晤士报》高等教育网站（www.thetimeshighereducation.com）的报道，继英国大学学术研究水平排名（REF）之后，英国政府又出台了英国大学教学质量排名（TEF）。

TEF 是 Teaching Excellence Framework的简称，是英国政府会同独立的教育评估机构，制定的英国大学教学质量评估体系，包括三个评估参数：通过全英学生满意度调查 （National Student Survey，简称NSS）考量学生对教学的满意度、学生辍学率、学生就业率。

最终评出Gold、Silver、Bronze三个级别，Gold级最高，Bronze级最低。

评选的结果将直接影响学费的走向，Gold级英国大学的学费涨幅将最大，Silver级的按照通胀水平涨学费，Bronze级的将维持当前学费。

从TEF排名结果看，出现了与REF排名大相径庭的结果。以学术、科研见长的罗素集团（Russell Group）的24所英国大学中，只有8所获得Gold级，而伦敦政经、南安普顿、利物浦三所英国名校竟获得了Bronze级，令人大跌眼镜。

相反，很多在REF和《泰晤士报》排名中相对靠后的英国大学，在TEF上却风光无限。

不知道这样的反差，能否真正激励不同等级的大学提高教学质量。在2017年的结果出台前后，英国大学圈对此争议不断。

这次TEF的结果涵盖了134个公立大学和3个以大学名义运作的公司，但仍有相当一部分英国大学没有参加评估，这其中就包括了爱丁堡大学、格拉斯哥大学、阿伯丁大学、贝尔法斯特女王大学、克兰菲尔德大学（Cranfield University）等著名学府。

英国大学教学与科研的平衡，还需要一段时间的内部磨合，出现不稳定的因素是暂时的。从中期和长期发展趋势看，对国际留学生，特别是中国留学生，会产生积极的影响，并突显英国高等教育的教学实力。

附件：英国大学TEF排名

https：//www.timeshighereducation.com/news/teaching-excellence-framework-tef-results-2017 

University 

TEF Result

Arts University Bournemouth

Gold

Aston University

Gold

Bangor University

Gold

University of Bath

Gold

University of Birmingham

Gold

Bishop Grosseteste University

Gold

University of Buckingham

Gold

University of Cambridge

Gold

Conservatoire for Dance and   Drama

Gold

Coventry University

Gold

De Montfort University

Gold

University of Derby

Gold

University of Dundee

Gold

Edge Hill University

Gold

University of Essex

Gold

University of Exeter

Gold

Falmouth University

Gold

Harper Adams University

Gold

University of Huddersfield

Gold

Imperial College London

Gold

Keele University

Gold

University of Kent

Gold

Lancaster University

Gold

University of Law

Gold

University of Leeds

Gold

University of Lincoln

Gold

Liverpool Hope University

Gold

Liverpool Institute for   Performing Arts

Gold

Loughborough University

Gold

Newcastle University

Gold

University of Northampton

Gold

Norwich University of the Arts

Gold

University of Nottingham

Gold

Nottingham Trent University

Gold

University of Oxford

Gold

University of Portsmouth

Gold

Robert Gordon University

Gold

Rose Bruford College

Gold

Royal Academy of Music

Gold

Royal Central School of Speech   and Drama， University of London

Gold

Royal College of Music

Gold

Royal Northern College of Music

Gold

Royal Veterinary College

Gold

University of St Andrews

Gold

University of Surrey

Gold

Abertay University

Silver

Anglia Ruskin University

Silver

Anglo-European College of Chiropractic

Silver

University of the Arts London

Silver

Bath Spa University

Silver

University of Bedfordshire

Silver

Birkbeck， University of London

Silver

Birmingham City University

Silver

University of Bolton

Silver

Bournemouth University

Silver

University of Bradford

Silver

University of Brighton

Silver

University of Bristol

Silver

Brunel University London

Silver

Canterbury Christ Church   University

Silver

Cardiff Metropolitan University

Silver

Cardiff University

Silver

University of Central   Lancashire

Silver

University of Chester

Silver

University of Chichester

Silver

City， University of London

Silver

Courtauld Institute of Art

Silver

Durham University

Silver

University of East Anglia

Silver

University of Gloucestershire

Silver

University of Greenwich

Silver

Guildhall School of Music and   Drama

Silver

Heriot-Watt University

Silver

University of Hertfordshire

Silver

University of Hull

Silver

King’s College London

Silver

Leeds Beckett University

Silver

Leeds College of Art

Silver

Leeds Trinity University

Silver

University of Leicester

Silver

Liverpool John Moores   University

Silver

London South Bank University

Silver

University of Manchester

Silver

Manchester Metropolitan   University

Silver

Middlesex University

Silver

Newman University

Silver

Northumbria University

Silver

Oxford Brookes University

Silver

Queen Mary University of London

Silver

Ravensbourne

Silver

University of Reading

Silver

Royal Agricultural University

Silver

Royal Holloway， University of   London

Silver

University of Sheffield

Silver

Sheffield Hallam University

Silver

University of St Mark and St   John

Silver

St Mary’s University，   Twickenham

Silver

Staffordshire University

Silver

University of Sunderland

Silver

University of Sussex

Silver

Swansea University

Silver

Teesside University

Silver

University College Birmingham

Silver

University College London

Silver

University for the Creative   Arts

Silver

University of Warwick

Silver

University of West London

Silver

University of the West of   England

Silver

University of Winchester

Silver

University of Worcester

Silver

Wrexham Glyndŵr University

Silver

University of York

Silver

BPP University

Bronze

British School of Osteopathy

Bronze

Bucks New University

Bronze

University of Cumbria

Bronze

University of East London

Bronze

Goldsmiths， University of   London

Bronze

Kingston University

Bronze

University of Liverpool

Bronze

London Metropolitan University

Bronze

London School of Economics and   Political Science

Bronze

Plymouth College of Art

Bronze

Plymouth University

Bronze

University of Roehampton

Bronze

University of Salford

Bronze

Soas， University of London

Bronze

University of Southampton

Bronze

Southampton Solent University

Bronze

St George’s， University of   London

Bronze

Trinity Laban Conservatoire of   Music and Dance

Bronze

University of Suffolk

Bronze

University of Wales Trinity   Saint David

Bronze

University of Westminster

Bronze

University of Wolverhampton

Bronze

Writtle University College

Bronze

York St John University

Bronze