AS经济学:实证表述&规范表述的关键与例题分析

2018年01月28日 英国留学中心


本文来源于:CrazyALEVEL

ID:CrazyAlevel


实证表述:企图描述世界是什么的观点。

规范表述:企图描述世界应该如何运行的观点。


1、实证表述 Positive Statements


Positive statements are objective statements that can be tested or rejected by referring to the available evidence.positive statements are claims that attempt to describe the world as it is. Positive economics deals with objective explanation and the testing and rejection of theories. 


例如:


A rise in consumer incomes will lead to a rise in the demand for new cars.

A fall in the exchange rate will lead to an increase in exports overseas.

More competition in markets can lead to lower prices for consumers.

If the government raises the tax on beer, this will lead to a fall in profits of the brewers.

A reduction in income tax will improve the incentives of the unemployed to search for work.

A rise in average temperatures will increase the demand for chicken.

Poverty in the UK has increased because of the fast growth of executive pay. 


2、规范表述 Normative Statements


Normative statements express an opinion about what ought to be. They are subjective statements rather than objective statements – i.e. they carry value judgments.


例如:


The level of duty on petrol is too unfair and unfairly penalizes motorists.

The London congestion charge for drivers of petrol-guzzling cars should increase to £25 - three times the current charge.

The government should increase the national minimum wage to £6 per hour in order to reduce relative poverty.

The government is right to introduce a ban on smoking in public places.

The retirement age should be raised to 75 to combat the effects of our ageing population.

The government ought to provide financial subsidies to companies manufacturing and developing wind farm technology. 


这两种表述的关键区别在于我们如何来判断其有效性(validity)。


原则上,实证表述是可以通过对证据的检验来肯定或是否定的;而规范表述除了事实,还包括价值,判断一项政策是好是坏不仅仅看科学事实,还包含我们对伦理道德,宗教信仰,以及政治哲学的看法。


当然这两者也是互相关联的,实证分析会对规范分析产生影响,但规范分析结论不仅需要实证分析,还需要价值判断(Value judgement)。


下面来看一个例题:


What must be true of a positive statement?


A  It is one that can be shown to be correct or incorrect.

B  It is one that deals with positive changes in economic well being.

C  It is one that is true by definition.

D  It is one with which everyone is in agreement. 


答案:A 


首先从定义来看,positive statements are claims that attempt to describe the world as it is.实证表述是企图描述世界是什么的观点,换言之是对事实的一种客观描述。


既然是事实,我们就可以判断它的对错,与选项A相符。这里容易勿选成D,要注意的是,三人成虎,并非所有人都同意的就一定正确,可能由于人类认识的发展局限性而造成所有人都错误的结果。


而选项C中,定义表现的是所下定义的人的思想认识,也就是我们说的涉及个人的value judgement,因此不能判断为positive statement。



学习国际课程不仅仅是努力就够的,首先要做各方面的了解,制定学习规划,按照自己的计划一步一步来,学习的同时多了解些留学申请方面的信息,知己知彼才能最终踏入自己的dream school。


英国初高中课程辅导全面开班

🔥🔥🔥

爱德思/OCR/AQA/CIE

数学/物理/化学/经济/生物/英语

GCSE/IGCSE/A-Level辅导

按小时/按天/按年

小班/1V1授课

 PS

我们还有公开课和全年辅导课程!


END


加主页君微信详细咨询

联系方式在此

近期热门

英镑为何突然暴跌|UEA学姐江疏影|出国后档案去哪里|RH学姐莫文蔚

出国留学为什么还会回来|想留学该如何说服父母|英国海关违禁品汇总 |英式口音

遇到歪果仁抹黑中国该怎么办|恐怖小丑来袭英国|诈骗犯盯上留学生|听说读英国一年制硕士很水?

留学干货

QS世界大学排名|THE世界大学排名

CUG|Times|卫报英国大学排名

QS世界最全专业排名

牛剑申请攻略|UCL好申吗|转专业攻略|挂科攻略

杜伦|格拉斯哥|爱丁堡|帝国理工|LSE|华威

为什么读商科|Tier 4申请材料清单|雅思科普

英国留学生订机票攻略|英国中学行前会

英国兼职|英国超市|英国租房|这些公司实习工资3K镑

收藏 已赞